bark collar for puppy with separation anxiety?
i recently just posted a question about my dog who barks a lot due to separation anxiety.
I have done some research on bark collars after some people have suggesedt it, but I am curious what is the best and most effect but humane collar? I dont think i would want to use one that shocks, but there are sprays and ones that give off high sound waves.
My dog is only 5 months, and i read dogs under 6 months cant use the spray. I also read that bark collars shouldn’t be used for dogs with anxiety problems– true? I am running out of ideas and am afraid the manage of my building will make me give up the dog
yes, I have tried pretty all other solution, TV on, Kong toys, LONG walks before, ignoring him, crate training, etc.. Most people dont realize though, when a dog has separation anxiety, they could care less about any of those things. He could be passed out tired but the second he hears the keys, he will freak out. I could put a big piece of steak in front of him, but if i leave, he could care less about the steak and still cry and bark.
nosaj
26 Apr, 2010
Bark collar is NOT a good idea.Make sure the dog has plenty of exercise prior to being left alone.Leave a radio on playing classical music which helps to soothe the dog.Leave the dog with puzzle like toys that it has to work to get food or treats out of.Fill a kong toy with kibble and peanut butter and freeze it,things like that.
Punishing a dog for any type of anxiety is never a good idea.It’s likely to cause more harm.
EDIT:Maybe it’s time to consult a vet or behaviorist to see if it is sa or some other underlying problem.You’re asking for a lot from a 5 month old pup.Everything takes consistancy and time when it comes to dog training.There are no quick fixes.
My dog tore up furniture,rugs,walls etc.,barked,whined wouldn’t eat…until he had matured some…when left alone.He has been a model citizen for several years now.Have to put in time and effort to get results,you can’t just slap a band-aid or in this case a collar on it.
Brutus
26 Apr, 2010
There is one that just vibrates when given a signal. This collar has no health risks and will still distract the dog. But keep in mind this may not permanently solve the problem.
If the dog is obsessed with barking he will soon tune the collar out and continue the barking. Obsessive barking is a sign of bigger problems and you may need to contact a professional behaviorist.
Happy Paws Kennel
26 Apr, 2010
Preventing Separation Anxiety
It’s good for your dog or puppy to be comfortable when home alone. You can help him learn this if you take a little time and use these simple steps. Start as soon as you take your puppy home for the first time.
* Dogs like routine. Develop a schedule for your dog.
* Provide your dog with plenty of mental and physical activity.
* Practice Preventive Training.
* Crate train your dog. When done properly, the use of a crate is a great way to help your dog remain calm – and out of trouble!
* Crate him for short periods while you are present. For example, when you are watching television, put the dog in his crate and put the crate next to the sofa. Gradually increase the time crated. Reward quiet behavior with calm praise and perhaps a treat such as a kibble of dog food.
* Start leaving your dog or puppy alone in his crate – start with just a few minutes at a time.
* Gradually increase the time spent alone.
* Limit your attention shortly before leaving so it isn’t such a shock when you do leave.
* When you let your dog out of his crate, remain calm and keep the greetings to a minimum. You don’t want to make him all excited.
* Reward your dog with a piece of food and attention when he lies quietly away from you.
* Most dogs don’t need to be crated throughout their lives, but don’t rush freedom. Typically, dogs aren’t ready to be given unsupervised freedom in your home until they are approximately a year-and-a-half or older.
* For those who work, consider hiring a dog-walker or neighbor to give your dog a midday break. Keeping your schedule similar on weekends as on workdays can help make things easier for your dog.
TK at TMDF
26 Apr, 2010
An anti-barking collar may stop the behavior of barking but the problem will still be there and other behaviors will start up, such as property destruction, self-mutilation, and aggression. Can you take the puppy to a daycare? Even find someone who has a dog-friendly dog and will puppy-sit yours.
Jenny
26 Apr, 2010
A better and more humane solution is doggy day care.
Its not unreasonable for a dog to wail and howl when left alone; being alone is unnatural for dogs. They live with their families and in nature are never alone unless they choose to be. Puppies, especially, are never left alone.
None of the so-called "anti-bark collars work consistently enough to not make your dog confused. Don’t bother.
If there is no professional doggy day care in your area, hunt around for another dog owner –even consider advertising, perhaps in your building– for someone you could make a deal with to keep your dog during the day.
I took my dog to my parents’ house every day for 4 months until I could find another apartment.
Nat-Nat
26 Apr, 2010
I do not recommend to use one! Because my dog had one on her before we got her and now she wont bark at all!!! So that is not good!
P.S please make me best answer please
Cyrus
26 Apr, 2010
Well you can get it if you want it will stop the barking but not the whining.
Separation Anxiety is a mental issue, a bark collar wont stop the separation anxiety but will stop the separation anxiety bark, forget the spray don’t do much.